Writer: Stephen Abela Stephen Abela

Green Claims on Trial: How Europe Is Policing Greenwashing After the Allegro Fine

When Poland's consumer protection authority fined Allegro almost 55 million zloty on 18 November, the headline was about trees. The e-commerce platform had promised to plant one for every ten parcels its customers collected, and the regulator concluded that the promise did not work the way shoppers were told it would. Behind that story sits a larger shift. Across Europe, environmental claims in advertising are moving from a matter of brand reputation to a matter of law, with fines, binding rules and regulators that are prepared to check the arithmetic.


This Research Desk piece looks at how the Allegro case was built, how Poland's wider crackdown has developed, what the EU rules that came into application in September actually require, and why the picture across member states remains patchy.

Green Claims on Trial: How Europe Is Policing Greenwashing After the Allegro Fine - Sustainable Development Goals


The case that set the tone


The campaign, "Sadzimy drzewa za odbiór przesyłek w Allegro One", linked tree planting to the use of Allegro's own delivery service. Slogans told customers that for every ten parcels collected, the company would fund the planting of a seedling, and that a tree would be planted with a dedication in the customer's name.


UOKiK, the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection, found two practices that breached consumers' collective interests, according to the legal news service Prawo.pl. The first was the impression that a customer's choice caused a tree to be planted. In practice, the regulator said, the number of trees was set from the previous year's forecasts, so the planting decision was taken before customers chose the service, and in some cases a tree was already in the ground before it was assigned to anyone. The second was that extra conditions were not properly disclosed. Parcels had to be collected within a calendar year, and from January 2024 customers had to submit a dedication within a set period, without which no tree was planted or assigned. Notes from Poland reports that the dedication function was unavailable for 264 days in 2024.

Green Claims on Trial: How Europe Is Policing Greenwashing After the Allegro Fine - Key statistics


The fines were PLN 29,852,000 for the first practice and PLN 24,876,000 for the second, PLN 54,728,000 in total. UOKiK told Notes from Poland that several million trees, more than half of the total Allegro claimed, were never planted. The decision is not yet final and can be challenged in court. "Green claims must be truthful, specific and verifiable," said UOKiK president Tomasz Chróstny.


Poland's wider crackdown


The Allegro decision did not come out of nowhere. In July 2025 UOKiK opened proceedings against Allegro and three delivery companies, according to Notes from Poland: two charges against Allegro, three against InPost, four against DHL's Polish branch and six against DPD's Polish branch. The claims under scrutiny included "green fleet", "zero-emission" and "environmentally neutral", as well as InPost's statements about its parcel lockers and a carbon calculator in its app.


Notes from Poland reported at the time that each charge carried a potential fine of up to 10 per cent of a company's annual turnover. For context, it put Allegro's 2024 turnover at 10.9 billion zloty. The authority has since widened its scrutiny to other brands, including Bolt, Tchibo, Zara and L'Oréal Polska, and points to a 2025 EU consumer survey in which 43 per cent of Poles said environmental impact influenced their purchasing choices. That is the regulator's core argument: if green claims change what people buy, false ones distort competition as well as mislead.


Europe's new rulebook


Since 27 September 2026, the EU has had a sharper tool. Directive (EU) 2024/825, known as the Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition Directive or EmpCo, entered into force on 26 March 2024. Member states had to adopt national measures by 27 March 2026, and the rules apply from 27 September 2026 without a transition period, according to an October 2026 review by the law firm Mayer Brown.


The directive adds several practices to the EU's blacklist of commercial practices that are banned in all circumstances. Generic environmental claims such as "environmentally friendly", "green" or "eco" are prohibited unless the trader can show recognised excellent environmental performance, for example through the EU Ecolabel or an officially recognised type I ecolabel. Sustainability labels that are not based on a certification scheme or set up by public authorities are banned. So are claims about an entire product or business when only one aspect is concerned, and product-level claims of climate neutrality that rely on offsetting rather than on reductions in the product's own life-cycle impact.


Claims about future performance, such as a pledge to reach carbon neutrality by a given year, are not banned outright but must be backed by clear, verifiable commitments set out in a detailed implementation plan that is checked by an independent expert. Tree-planting promises of the Allegro type are not named specifically, but the directive's logic is the same as UOKiK's: a claim must describe a real, demonstrable effect.


A patchy transposition


A directive only bites when it is written into national law, and here the picture is uneven. According to Mayer Brown's review of EUR-Lex records as of 27 October 2026, eight member states had notified no transposition measures at all: Bulgaria, Czechia, Malta, Poland, Portugal, Slovenia, Spain and Sweden. France had work in progress only. Denmark adopted its measures in May 2025 and Slovakia in November 2025, while Hungary notified its measures on the application date itself.


That leaves an odd situation in which Poland's regulator is among the most active in Europe on greenwashing while the country has not yet formally transposed the new EU rules. UOKiK has been acting under existing consumer law, which already bans misleading practices. Companies operating across borders cannot rely on that gap, however: the directive applies to them in every market that has transposed it, and courts in the laggard states may still interpret national law in its light.


The law that stalled


EmpCo was meant to be one half of a pair. In March 2023 the European Commission proposed a Green Claims Directive that would have required companies to substantiate explicit environmental claims with evidence before using them, and to have that evidence checked. The Commission's case rested on a 2020 study which found that 53.3 per cent of the environmental claims examined were vague, misleading or unfounded, and that 40 per cent were completely unsubstantiated. It also counted some 230 different green labels in use in the EU.


The proposal ran into trouble in 2025. The final round of negotiations between the institutions was cancelled in July of that year, according to the law firm Loyens & Loeff. In its 2027 work programme, published on 4 November 2026, the Commission said it intends to withdraw the proposal because it is unlikely to win sufficient support in the Council within a reasonable time. Until that procedure is complete, the proposal remains formally pending, but in practice the EU's anti-greenwashing framework now rests on EmpCo and on national enforcement.


What to watch next


Three things will show whether the Allegro decision marks a turning point. The first is the court process: if Allegro appeals, the judgment will test how strictly Polish judges read a promise linked to customer behaviour. The second is the outcome of UOKiK's other open cases against courier firms and retail brands, which concern exactly the kind of fleet and carbon claims that EmpCo now restricts. The third is transposition. Until Poland and the other seven states that had notified nothing by late October adopt national measures, the EU will have a single rulebook on paper and a patchwork in practice.


Why it matters


Greenwashing cases used to end in a corrected advert. The Allegro fine shows they can now cost tens of millions, and EmpCo turns many vague claims into outright breaches. With the Green Claims Directive set to be withdrawn, the burden of keeping green marketing honest falls on national regulators, so how actively each one enforces the rules will decide whether consumers in Warsaw, Madrid or Stockholm get the same protection.


Comments

Write a comment...

Get the Latest News to Your Inbox

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive news and updates.