Writer: Stephen Abela Stephen Abela

Ireland's Fossil Fuel Exit Roadmap Criticised for Lacking Dates and Detail

Ireland has published a national roadmap for moving away from fossil fuels, but environmental and development groups say it offers little that is new. The Transition Away From Fossil Fuels roadmap was released by the Government at the COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Türkiye, and is intended to drive a steady decline in the use of oil, gas, petrol and diesel across transport, heating, power generation and industry, The Irish Times reported on 18 November.


Ireland joins a growing number of countries that have published, or committed to publishing, national plans of this kind. The document itself states that it brings together measures already in place or in development. It does not set new dates for phasing out any fossil fuel, and it restates the long-standing national goals of halving carbon emissions by 2030 and reaching climate neutrality by 2050.

Ireland's Fossil Fuel Exit Roadmap Criticised for Lacking Dates and Detail - Sustainable Development Goals


The gap between those goals and current progress is wide. Minister for Climate Darragh O'Brien has already acknowledged that the 2030 target will not be met, with projections pointing to a reduction of around 25 per cent at best. Ireland still relies on fossil fuels for more than 80 per cent of its energy, and the Climate Change Advisory Council has said the country needs to be free of them by 2039. Asked what level of reliance to expect by then, the minister would say only that it would be lower, adding that some dependence on fossil fuels will remain in 2029.


Campaigners were critical. Friends of the Earth Ireland chief executive Deirdre Duffy described the plan as "deeply cynical", arguing that it lacks credible actions, timelines, implementation pathways, investment details and progress metrics. She also pointed out that it does not mention data centres, even though their growth is pushing up gas demand for electricity generation.


Trócaire's Sinéad Loughran called the roadmap "wholly inadequate" and criticised continuing plans for new fossil fuel infrastructure, in particular the liquefied natural gas terminal planned for Co Clare. Opportunity Green's Sorcha Tunney said the absence of any measure to curb demand for air travel was a significant omission, since the plan relies only on sustainable aviation fuel and more efficient aircraft to cut aviation emissions.


Mr O'Brien defended the document as setting out the principles and the tasks needed for the transition. He said more detailed actions will follow in the Climate Action Plan, which is due to be published next month after a long delay. RTÉ reported that electrification of heat, transport and industry sits at the centre of the roadmap, building on a separate electrification plan that includes grid upgrades and more renewable generation.


For businesses and households, the practical signal is that the direction of travel remains the same while the detail is still to come. Companies with significant oil and gas use in heating, fleets or processes will need to watch the Climate Action Plan closely for the specific measures, timelines and support schemes that the roadmap itself does not provide.


Why it matters

Ireland's own advisers say it should be free of fossil fuels by 2039, yet the roadmap names no milestone on the way there. That gap between scientific advice and policy is exactly what lenders, insurers and supply-chain customers now look at when they assess transition risk.


Comments

Write a comment...

Get the Latest News to Your Inbox

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive news and updates.